Thank you so much for the suggestion! I just did a horary chart with the question "does this look like a relationship breakup?" I have attached the chart.
Good morning, Ms. Francine...
Welcome to our cosy confines..of the Horary section...
For many years, this horary section has always been perceived... as the back door or 'trash can' of Noel Tyl's fine discussion forum. Most of the main 'stars' of this site (and they know who they
are? LOL) have tended to ignore this section over the years...
Maybe it's because they don't like 'me' or Yilmaz? I am not really sure...you'll have to ask the critics... LOL
However, due to my own perserverance and enthusiasm for Horary astrology...this section is finally receiving the audience that it richly deserves...and we are now attracting exceptionally good horaryists... like Jim and Halina...and people not even interested in horary astrology... are starting to visit this section...
As I have mentioned, many times before, formulating the question is critical in horary work.
Here's the bottom line ? If you pose a crappy question, you will get a crappy answer...
Therefore, your original question was too vague and the end result was nonsense...a completely muddled answer.
I see that Jim and Waterbird were frustrated about that and I would be, too ?
Based on what I have read, I think that the advice given to you by Jim and Waterbird is very good and also, therefore, there is really not much that I can add, here ?
waterbird is right, though. You can only ask one question. and then, you must WAIT, until asking again ?
I would wait about one year before asking this question again.
Meanwhile, it sounds to me like you already know the outcome of this question, in your mind ? You think that it is doomed for failure and therefore, your question seems tainted already ?
Not unusual, though, as many parents think THEY know best about the affairs of their offspring...But here's the issue...once they are adults, you have to stop meddling in their affairs and let them make their own decisions, for better or worse...
UNLESS you want to be perceived as an Adolf Hitler...
You should try to be more objective about whatever question you ask, in future ?
In other words, " let Go...and let God" as they say ?
In these types of biased situations, I would highly recommend that you ask the question to another person, instead of answering it yourself? In other words, go to a professional astrologer or a trusted friend with your question, versus asking it yourself ?
You will always get a better answer if you do that !
Good luck to you,
p.s. btw, you can't formulate a question based SOLELY on an astrology aspect... ! for good or bad !
It doesn't work that way !