Hello Noel,
I always find your writings inspiring and masterfully written.
It's one thing to be able to cut the chaff from the wheat, but it's a gift to be able to do it so creatively with words so that it is always ENJOYABLE to read. Thank you for the generosity of your time/energy to help bring all of Astrology, UP!
You da man!
The Solar Arcs to the Aries Point, I think, is a very important article as many might MISS this very important clue, if not for your personal direction as to its importance.
As for Framing Questions, it is essential to not only know WHAT to ask, but HOW to ask it. Astrologers (regularly) say so many UNDENIABLE truths to clients, that a client (naturally) can come to hang on EVERY WORD THAT COMES FROM THE ASTROLOGER'S MOUTH as if it were God-given. 1,000,000 thanks to Noel for putting the NEEDS of the client front and center (in Astrology) and for being circumspect with just what we "give" to the client. I usually begin an astrological consultation with a question relating to previous astrological "experiences" that the client has had. I have learned to do this because there is often a deep misconception (at least as far as what I do) and it's important to get past that and onto a clean slate from the beginning. Believe me, I have heard some HORROR stories. It's probably a bit more necessary here in Germany, where it is NORMAL for someone to consult an astrologer. (no stigma attached) In other words, many here (from my experience) have had an astrological experience of one variety or another, but RARELY is it a positive remembrance. Many times it is bad enough that I am surprised that the client ever ventured for a follow up experience!!!
I especially "resonated" to the Hearing the Melody article. I notice that I often say to myself to stop THINKING/ANALYSING and to just "FEEL" what it might be like to be in the client's shoes. (ie. to try and "gestaltingly" comprehend the chart and to metaphorically "put it on")
Music seems a natural "relation" to Astrology, since both are often very subjective! (Don't get me wrong, the chart is OBJECTIVE, but the "translation" is often subjective.)
I read Don's comments earlier and I can see where he is coming from (in terms of the "Melody" article).
As an example, take the hauntingly beautiful song "Wonderful Tonight" by Eric Clapton. It is "heard" and remembered as a beautiful love song, an admiration for a beautiful, loved woman. When you read the history of the song, ie. what the author was SAYING when they wrote the song, the REASON THE SONG EXISTS, you understand that it is actually tongue in cheek. The many "you look wonderful tonight" phrasings through the song are a never-ending, required response to her (Pattie Boyd's) "uncontrolled vanity". (Of course, it's from the author's perspective. It is a reaction to "how do I look?" "how do I look now?" "...and now?" "...and now?" "...and NOW?") My point is...melody/music is like that.
Play
Clair de lune for three different people. One hears it as hauntingly beautiful. Another is unmoved by it, while a third is reminded to put lye, a shovel, and duct tape on the shopping list.
To tie that to Astrology, I recently read an intersting article about (paraphrased) seeing the "good" in Hitler's horoscope. The point wasn't that Hitler was good, the point was that KNOWING IT WAS HITLER'S CHART always influenced the way that his horoscope was/is read. If we were to put Hitler's chart in with two "dummy" charts and present it to 10 very good astrologers (who can't remember/discern that it's Hitler's chart), surely some of them could find
something positive to say about the CHART. In this sense, we have ONE chart, but (at least) two very distinct "melodies."
As another example, how many Astrologers would have read O.J. Simpson's chart EXACTLY the same way 4 months before Nicole's murder as 4 months after??? It's one chart, but capable of infinite melodies. One can hear what one wants, but it's ever the owner of the chart who
ultimately CALLS THE TUNE.
Bringing it home, how many would look at Jesus' chart and hear Handel's
Messiah? Many other melodies would surely come up short, comparatively.
Thank you again, Noel. Always food for thought.
Always.OD'dOnLifeItself