Okay, well i think the Sun-Moon opposing Neptune person ought to be the artist but is in actual fact the murderer. Has Pluto out of bound in the 8th house.
The Sun in Cancer person has to be Robin Williams, I don't remember his exact chart except for all the water Sun-Moon-Rising. With Moon-Venus on the Nodal Axis I think he's basically a lover, not a killer. but he did kill himself, if this is who he is.
How does Person B's chart, with Scorpio rising, angular Pluto (in 9th tightly conj MC and also tightly conj Mercury), and a Mars-Uranus conjunction in the 8th house tell you the person is "basically a lover, not a killer"? Don't those things suggest the opposite? Not to mention, that person has Moon in Pisces tightly opposed by Venus in Virgo -- which, in a man, can point to a classic "virgin-whore" dichotomy when it comes to the women in his life -- and that aspect is also angular across the 4th/10th, indicating family issues that may have created that dichotomy. I'm asking honestly because I think it's your belief that that's the chart of widely loved actor Robin Williams, rather than the actual astrology of the chart itself, that makes you say that.
And how does Person A's chart with nothing in Scorpio, nothing but Pluto in the 8th and it makes no hard aspects to anything unless you count a 10-degree orb (in which case Pluto opposes Venus), and Mars in airy Gemini opposite a Sagittarius ascendant... how does that chart look like a killer?
I'm genuinely interested in this. I've been doing astrology for over thirty years and I would not have pegged either chart as that of a killer, although I might have leaned more towards the first one for that if I'd had to choose. What I WOULD have said is that both charts were consistent with the person having some type of mental illness, specifically:
Person B: consistent with something like bipolar disorder (formerly known as manic depression). Mars conj Uranus fits the manic side, the megadose of water (Sun Moon Asc all water) fits with mood swings, Pluto tightly conjunct Mercury can be more intensity and darkness than the everyday mind can handle, and the two oppositions (Jupiter-Neptune and Moon-Venus) also fit with swinging back and forth between extremes.
Person A: consistent with psychosis and/or psychopathy. Psychosis is basically what most people think of as insanity: crazy delusions, hallucinations, etc. A Sun-Moon conjunction in Pisces opposite Neptune, not to mention Mercury in Pisces too (though far from that conjunction), easily fits with that, and with Sag rising and angular Jupiter conjunct Mars, one might expect delusions of grandeur or "specialness." And I recall a study that found prominent Sagittarius, Jupiter and/or Neptune very common among charming psychopaths, who use that charm to trick or lure victims into coming with them, and to avoid getting caught.
Both of them: drug and/or alcohol problems a strong possibility.
But of course, the overwhelming majority of people with strong Sag, Jupiter and/or Neptune aren't even violent, much less psycho killers. Ditto the overwhelming majority of people with Scorpio rising, angular Pluto, etc.
And yes, perhaps I picked someone too well known for one of the charts; it was indeed Robin Williams. I can pick more obscure people next time, but it is things like this "who's the killer?" experiment that make me tend to believe that a chart is less like a picture of someone's destiny (this one a killer, that one an actor) and more like a prism through which a particular and specific soul is refracted. In other words it is the person themselves, the soul, who is the killer or the actor and the chart just shows us what type of killer or actor they are.
The second chart is that of John Wayne Gacy, who tricked dozens of teenage boys and young men to come to his house for somewhere to live and/or a job opportunity, and then drugged, raped and killed them. That is pure evil and I just don't think you can see EVIL ITSELF in a chart. But you can see that if he was evil, he acted out that evil using used trickery and the powers of persuasion (Sag, Mars/Jupiter conj in Gemini...).
